Friday, April 27, 2012

Mad...


    I must admit that I do not believe Hamlet's madness to be true. His manic disposition seems to be nothing more than a reaction to his father's undoubted murder. Hamlet is hurt and upset, and he processes these emotions in a way that comes across as madness to other characters. Thus far, he never seems to slip beneath the blue of the sea of manic depressive madness (which I feel he would undoubtedly experience in light of the circumstances of his father's death). He doesn't fall off the deep end and over the edge into a spiraling, all-consuming madness. Hamlet more or less, with great sorrow (I do not doubt the truth nor depth of his melancholy) mourns over the loss of his father. He does not rave like a the lunatic he is supposed to be.
     Hamlet is, to me, just a teenager filled with passion and rage with no outlet for it besides words. It's almost as though, as long as he keeps telling himself he'll avenge his father, it will be so and order will return to his world. He needs to continue to feed on that promise to himself and his father's ghost in order to not plunge into madness. He's quite sane actually in my opinion. Yes, revenge has consumed his thoughts but he still remains logical in how he goes about trying to extract this revenge. He does think before he acts. I believe that Polonius's murder was a mere accident as he thought Polonius to be Claudius. His apathy over it was more cold calculation. He never liked Polonius as he stole something precious from Hamlet: Ophelia. In Hamlet's mind, he rid the chess board in his head of one more loathsome piece.
     If that is the case, than Hamlet is still following close to his plot to out Claudius and extract vengeance for his father. That kind of cold calculation is more sociopathic as opposed to psychotic. He seems well aware of what he's doing, playing people like instruments and causing dissension through-out the palace. It's like it's a game to him. That's how I truly feel Hamlet is acting. He is quite the intelligent young man and I feel that he is going about his revenge like one would go about playing a game of chess or, more aptly, cat and mouse. He's getting a thrill out of playing at madness and causing Claudius grief while biding his time before he sends him to hell. Which, Hamlet's decision to make sure Claudius goes to purgatory I feel also supports the notion that Hamlet is only feigning madness and is quite in control of himself and his actions.
     Furthermore, when one compares Hamlet's "madness" to the massive break from reality that Ophelia has, I feel that there is no contest that Hamlet's madness is not quite true. Ophelia completely loses touch with reality after the forced purging of Hamlet from her life and the death of her father. She is bawling, melancholy mess. She falls apart. Hamlet never loses his wits about him and certainly does not fall to tiny, irreparable pieces as Ophelia does. He still shows poise and self-restraint where as Ophelia cannot seem to control her outbursts. She's broken. The loss of all the men in her life she loves and the soul-wrenching woe it breathes to life slashes her heart in two along with her mind and ends up literally drowning her in sorrow. She drowns in her own sorrow, a victim of her madness where as Hamlet appears to always be the master of his madness.
     Therefore, it is my conclusion that Hamlet's madness is merely feigned. He is not a victim of it. He has not succumbed to it as Ophelia has. He is in full reign of it, turning it on and off as he pleases in order to play the people around him as the pawns he sees them as in his head. He may be sociopathic, the way he disposes and treats people in his life, but I do feel he is quite aware of all he's doing. The death of Hamlet's father has not broken his mind, only his heart. He's acting out of passion. Well, I guess one would have to say he's speaking  out of passion as it seems he's never going to actually do anything about his grief.

***Just got back from seeing The Raven movie and it was quite worth the watch.***

5 comments:

toledo.daniel said...

I like how you went inside Hamlet's mind and compared it to a chess game. Hamlet does seem to be making a game out of his revenge by using everyone as pawns. Also, from your comparison of Hamlet's madness to Ophelia's madness, it is obvious that Hamlet is not suffering from true madness but rather his emotions. If he was truly mad, he wouldn't still have his smarts or his self , but would be as loopy as Ophelia.

Krista~ said...

aw yay, finally someone who shares my belief. I too believe Hamlet isn't really descending into madness. I liked your comparison to Ophelia's breakdown, especially when you say "She drowns in her own sorrow, a victim of her madness where as Hamlet appears to always be the master of his madness." I also liked how you used "drowning" it serves as a good analogy and fits her death well. Great job!

Nierah Jinwright said...

YES! Someone who has the same belief as me! Eventhough I took a similar approach as of why Hamlet isn't insane, I agree with everything you have to say that was different. He is a teenage boy, filled with anger, and drama. Hamlet is FULLY aware of his actions and decisions thoughtout the entire novel. Whether he cares about his rash decisions is a different question. Opehelia's madness is clearly not feigned, and if Hamlet was indeed crazy, he would have had the same fate as her. Early, unexplainable death.

stw923 said...

Does your opinion of Hamlet change knowing that he was probably 30 years old and not a teenager (or even really close to a teenager's age)? In addition, Hamlet is not merely a boy - he is a man with the weight of a country on his shoulders. He was raised to be king... (Well written Kel!)

GlumPlum said...

Would Hamlet's age change my opinion? I would have to say it would make his actions even more immature. His feigned madness, acting like he's playing a game would make him quite unfit to take the throne in my opinion. He's supposed to be future king and the way he's acting and settling things is just not really showing that potential at all.